DISQUS

Joshi · 11 months ago

Uwe Boll... no really.

Elizabeth · 11 months ago

Every time I think of a director, I realize that the material is beneath them. Actually, I think that was probably a large part of the problem here too, Hardwicke tried to make it into something she could care about, and that was what made the studio and the fangirls angry.

seventeen · 11 months ago

Elizabeth is right.

Twilight is, in essence, a very boring book with scenes on loop. Catherine changed all that, and made it into something a lot of other people could like. While the movie was terrible, it was better than the book in so many ways because it had a bit of personality. I'm upset that by giving some soul to the material, she had to pay the price.

David G · 11 months ago

So...the director rewrote the story for film??I'm confused. Hardwicke was terrible for this. It seemed like this could have become an ok movie. Instead her editing and lack of mutiple takes and ability to tell the actors to do a scene better made it horrible. The story and visual were decent but the acting just made it trash.

Carolyn · 11 months ago

Whoever wrote the screenplay did a great job of adapting the book. And the things that were changed were for the better. I agree with David G that the problem was the visual effects and, most importantly the acting which was all the director. I have much greater hope for the second movie with a different director behind the wheel.

NARC13 · 11 months ago

Michael Bay.

Davebaxter1989 · 11 months ago

I could actually not care less haha

Nish · 11 months ago

I think this film needs a female director with an eye for big budget action. But hollywood seems to lack those.

mike · 11 months ago

i would hire John Woo

John Demetry · 11 months ago

Catherine Hardwicke is the perfect director for this: nothing in the book compares to the moment Bella enters Bio class in the film... Edward -- repulsed -- winged like an angel (flanked by a stuffed owl), Bella -- self-conscious -- her hair billows against the fan. The danger of sexuality, the grace of Desire. Beautiful. I was thought Hardwicke could continue in order to work through the ideas she introduces. It was like My So-Called Life with Godfather ambitions. In that tradition, I had hopes Part II would be better. Only one person could have gotten those performances from those actors (while d.p. Elliot Davis got the perfect look). This is a real shame. Oh well, here's praying Kathryn Bigelow or Sturla Gunnarsson or Neil Jordan or Patrice Chereau (!!!omg!1) will be hired to take over "New Moon". But something tells me they're not looking for artists (Chris Weitz?????? ugh). Anyone who directs "New Moon" should do screenings of "The Story of Adele H.", "Godfather Part II" & "III", and "The Company of Wolves" for inspiration and instruction.

Isabella- issie · 9 months ago

i totally agree with you John Catherine Made it Better
LIke you said i noticed first thing he had wings like and angel and he covers his nose
she made it interesting and good
Its really gay theyre dumping her
i hope all the fans out there protest and then this stupid chris weitz can go bite his own butt because i think Catherine done a wonderful job
although chris done Golden compass that movie was the best..
so its sorta even
BUT!!.............................GIRLS ARE BETTER ;D lol
but i still think catherine is good but.. Chris might make this a little competititon see what ones better twlight or new moon?
well .. were going to have to wait to find this out
I CANT WAIT TIL NOVEMBER - dies